Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, nestled in the heart of Indianapolis at 9165 Otis Ave, is a true gem for pizza aficionados and sandwich lovers alike. Specializing in handcrafted pizzas and an array of hearty sandwiches, this vibrant eatery brings a refreshing and creative twist to classic Italian-American comfort food.
Their pizza offerings are a celebration of bold flavors and thoughtful craftsmanship. A standout is the renowned "Inferno" pizza, which balances a robust spice with impeccable toppings and a crust that manages to be both crispy and tender—perfectly customizable for those who prefer their crust a bit crunchier. For those exploring lighter or plant-based options, the "Jockamo Special" is a revelation, praised for its fresh ingredients and satisfying complexity.
But the culinary excitement doesn’t stop at pizza. The sandwich menu shines with hearty selections such as the Italian Beef sandwich, a customer favorite described as slightly spicy and immensely flavorful, complemented by a unique balsamic dipping sauce that enhances every bite. Other delicious choices include classics like the Meatball Sub, Reubano, and inventive options like the Korean Beef sandwich, each crafted with quality ingredients and an eye for balance and depth.
Beyond the food, Jockamo Upper Crust offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes diners feel right at home. Visitors speak highly of the friendly and attentive service—highlighting staff members who go the extra mile to accommodate groups large and small, and creating an ambiance that’s both relaxed and lively. Whether you’re popping in for a quick lunch, enjoying a casual family dinner, or grabbing takeout for a night in, the welcoming environment enhances the overall experience.
Complementing the menu are classic macrobrews like Bud Light and Yuengling Lager, making it easy to pair your meal with a refreshing beverage. Kids are not forgotten, with playful menu items like the PBJ Pie and Jelly Pita Pizza catering to younger palates.
Many guests have celebrated Jockamo not only for its top-notch food but also for the thoughtful touches—the crispy garlic shavings on the lasagna pizza, the creamy Parmesan sauce paired with breadsticks, and the patient, gracious service that shines even as closing time approaches. Frequent visitors appreciate the authenticity and passion that the staff pours into every dish, and occasional diners often leave feeling delighted by a meal that far exceeds expectations.
In essence, Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is more than just a local pizza spot—it’s a culinary experience that artfully blends flavor, quality, and genuine hospitality. Whether you’re a devoted pizza fan or simply in search of a memorable meal in Indianapolis, Jockamo promises a delicious journey you’ll be eager to revisit.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Joby Jerrells
03/12/2025
Jockamo’s usually gets props for their pizza, which are well-deserved, but I wanted to focus on my favorite sandwich, the Italian Beef. Slightly spicy and delicious. Served with a balsamic dipping sauce that pairs well with the sandwich. Good lunch menu! Stop by for a slice or a sandwich, you won’t be disappointed! This is an independent, uncompensated review.
Nathan Lammers
30/11/2025
In town for a volleyball tournament, and this was right next to the Tru Hotel. They were able to accommodate our large group of 11. Joey gave some great suggestions on what to order. They have a large selection of specialty pizzas. I went with "The Inferno," which was a good choice. I prefer a little more crisp on my pizza, so I went with a 4. Everyone in our group enjoyed the meal, though. Would definitely eat here again if we are in the area again.
Angie Etienne
04/11/2025
We are from out of town and we arrived and were welcomed immediately! I forgot to take a picture of the breadsticks but they were amazing and the creamy Parmesan sauce was very good as well as the pizza and cheese sauce! The lasagna pizza was phenomenal and the garlic shavings made it marvelous!! Our waitress was so patient and kind and they were even getting ready to close and she was so gracious!! Highly recommend! Never made us feel rushed or put out with us arriving 30 minutes before they closed!!
PJ
20/10/2025
Back on my plant base journey best pizza I ever had The Jockamo Special. Love the environment as well will be back for sure.
Julie Bertoni
29/09/2025
Man, what a great surprise! We were passing through town and staying nearby, and the hotel staff member told us to try this place. The staff were awesome with me adding a couple things to the takeout order when I came to pick it up. I was not expecting to be blown away by the food, but it was SO delicious! I got the Mediterranean salad with chicken and it was amazing. My husband loved his Italian beef sandwich and my daughter's pizza was fabulous. Would definitely recommend to anyone.
Travis Whiteside
24/09/2025
Food was really good. The service was excellent. The young man in there was hustling around helping out the waitress. They only had one working tables at this time. I would recommend.
Shirley Green
10/09/2025
First time trying. Hubby and I enjoying part of our 41st anniversary weekend. We hung out enjoyed the yummy pizza and atmosphere was nice. The waitress was warm and pleasant. A spot I would return!